Finding Authenticity: What 20 Years at the Chamber of Commerce Taught Me
Sherry Menor-McNamara’s journey into leadership didn’t begin with a clear, linear plan—it began with pressure, discipline, and deeply ingrained expectations. Raised in a strict Japanese-Filipino household, she grew up in an environment where excellence was the baseline and anything less demanded improvement. That upbringing instilled a relentless work ethic, but it also planted the seeds of self-doubt—an internal voice that constantly questioned whether anything she did was ever “good enough.”
For years, that voice followed her—from being a high-achieving student to navigating UCLA, to exploring careers in law, entertainment, and public service. On the surface, her path may have looked impressive and diverse, but underneath it was a deeper search: Who am I really, beyond expectations? That question would take decades—and a 20-year career at the Chamber of Commerce—to answer.
The Long Road to Finding Purpose
Like many high achievers, Sherry didn’t immediately know what she wanted to do. Her early career was marked by exploration—working as a legal assistant, in entertainment, in public policy, and even in Japan with Sony. Each experience added a layer of perspective, but none fully clicked until she returned home to Hawai‘i and discovered the world of public policy and business advocacy.
Joining the Chamber of Commerce wasn’t part of a grand plan—it was a moment of alignment. The mission to support businesses resonated deeply, especially given her mother’s struggles as a small business owner. What started as a role in government affairs evolved into a calling. Over time, that calling turned into leadership, and eventually into becoming President & CEO—despite initially feeling unprepared and unsure of herself.
Leadership Without Confidence—and Learning on the Fly
When Sherry stepped into the CEO role, she didn’t feel ready. She had never managed a team, run an organization, or reported to a board. More importantly, she didn’t yet believe in herself. The same inner critic from childhood resurfaced, causing her to second-guess decisions and feel out of place—especially as the first female CEO in the Chamber’s long history.
What changed wasn’t overnight confidence—it was a shift in mindset. Through mentors, lived experience, and intentional growth, she learned to “own the role” even before she fully felt it. Leadership became less about having all the answers and more about being willing to learn, ask for help, and move forward anyway. Over time, confidence didn’t come from perfection—it came from action.
The Hidden Cost of Achievement
Success often comes with an invisible weight. For Sherry, years of striving created a pattern of internal pressure—constantly pushing, constantly proving, constantly questioning. Like many leaders, she found that the higher she climbed, the lonelier it could feel.
That pressure eventually led her inward. Therapy, self-reflection, and surrounding herself with supportive people helped her confront the deeper patterns driving her behavior. She began to recognize that achievement alone wouldn’t create fulfillment. The real work was learning to quiet the noise, let go of external validation, and ask a different question: Am I being true to myself?
Redefining Strength: Vulnerability and Authenticity
One of the most powerful lessons from her journey is that vulnerability is not weakness—it’s a form of strength. For someone raised to keep emotions private and “figure it out on your own,” opening up didn’t come naturally. It took time, trust, and repeated effort to feel comfortable sharing honestly.
But that shift unlocked something deeper: authenticity. Instead of trying to meet everyone else’s expectations, she began focusing on what felt aligned—doing work that mattered, helping others, and showing up as herself. That didn’t mean ignoring responsibility or professionalism; it meant finding a balance between the role she played and the person she truly was.
Why Mission Matters More Than Ever
After 20 years at the Chamber, one principle stands above the rest: clarity of mission. In a role filled with competing demands, diverse stakeholders, and constant pressure, the mission becomes the anchor. For Sherry, that mission is simple but powerful—to make Hawai‘i a better place by building a stronger, healthier economy.
When everything gets noisy—and it often does—coming back to that purpose provides direction. It shifts the focus from problems to solutions, from individual pressure to collective impact. And it reinforces a key leadership truth: when you believe deeply in what you’re doing, the challenges become part of the journey, not a reason to stop.
Becoming Who You Already Are
Looking back, the biggest lesson isn’t about business, policy, or leadership—it’s about identity. For years, Sherry tried to meet expectations, emulate others, and prove her worth. But the real breakthrough came when she stopped trying to be someone else and started embracing who she already was.
Authenticity isn’t something you achieve once—it’s something you practice over time. It requires letting go of fear, trusting your voice, and accepting that not everyone will understand or agree. But in that process, something shifts. You become more grounded, more free, and ultimately more effective—not just as a leader, but as a person.
The Ongoing Journey
Even after two decades of leadership, the journey isn’t finished. Growth continues. Challenges remain. There are still moments of doubt, reflection, and learning. But the difference now is perspective.
Instead of asking, “Is this good enough?” the question becomes, “What more can I do—and how can I do it as myself?”
CLICK HERE to SUBSCRIBE to our YouTube channel
Podcast: Play in new window | Download
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | RSS